business-strategy
The Michigan Service Year Runs on Three Numbers, Not a Strategic Plan
November in Michigan is when the service year goes quiet. The snow plows have contracts signed but little to push until the first storm. The HVAC trucks are running a handful of furnace calls a day instead of forty. The landscapers have wrapped up and the roofers are watching the forecast. For owners, this is the month where you finally get an afternoon with a blank page, and the question on that page is almost always the same one: what is the plan for next year?
Most plans I see are written for an average year, and an average year does not happen. The work arrives in waves. Spring storms make April the busiest phone month for roofers. June through August swamps HVAC and plumbing. December is slow for half the trades and slammed for the other half. A plan built on an average month will have you hiring in March, panicking in July, and cutting costs in October, every single year, with the plan itself never blamed. This post is about the kind of planning that survives the waves instead of getting washed out by them.
The argument in one sentence: a Michigan service business does not need a strategic plan so much as it needs a seasonal operating plan, a cash rhythm, and an honest capacity number. Everything else people put on the whiteboard is decoration until those three exist.
The four seasons of a Michigan service business
The year has four distinct economic seasons, and the calendar matters as much as the weather. Here is how the waves land for most trades around Flint, Grand Blanc, Fenton, and down through the Detroit suburbs.
Spring, roughly March through May, is the demand spike. Snow melts, gutters reveal themselves, roofs show the damage winter did, and homeowners who shelved projects in January start calling. For exterior trades, spring is when the whole year's margin gets built. The phone outruns the calendar in this window, and the business that answers fastest takes jobs the slower one never quotes. April phone volume for roofers can triple a February day. The constraint in spring is never demand. It is capacity and response speed.
Summer, June through August, is the peak. HVAC and plumbing live here, at full trucks and long weeks. Margin per job is usually thinnest here because everyone is busy and price conversations go short. Crews are tired by mid-July, and the scheduling board becomes the most important document in the office. The trap in summer is accepting every job and letting the slow ones, the warranty visits, and the paperwork slide, because the tax on that arrives in November.
Fall, September through November, is the cliff. Demand falls off a week at a time, and every owner feels it even though nothing changed about their quality or their ads. This is also the season for the maintenance work that books the next year: furnace checks in October, gutter cleaning before the leaves finish, winterization calls. Businesses that treat fall as the pre-season for winter do well. Businesses that treat fall as a failure of summer slow down twice.
Winter, December through February, splits the trades in two. Snow removal, insulation, and indoor remodeling stay busy. Landscaping, roofing, and concrete largely stop. For that second group, winter is not downtime. It is the only window in the year with enough quiet to do the work that makes next year run: pricing, hiring, systems, vendor agreements, and the marketing that has to be in place before the first warm Saturday.
The three numbers that replace the plan
A strategic plan usually comes out of a document. An operating plan comes out of three numbers. If you have these three, the plan writes itself in an afternoon. If you do not, the prettiest strategy deck in the world is a wish list.
Number one is cash runway, counted in slow-season days. Runway is the cash you hold divided by the cash you burn in a normal month, and the version that matters here is the one measured against the slow months, not the good ones. A shop that holds one month of expenses can survive a two-week lull and nothing longer. A shop with three months of runway can buy equipment in January at winter prices and hire in February before the season opens. The difference between those two businesses is not effort or talent. It is what the margin earned in June was allowed to become.
The cleanest way to think about it: the good months fund the year, and the slow months spend it. Every margin dollar that leaves in July, on a truck the business did not need or a job it should have declined, is a dollar that has to be found again in February, when it cannot be found.
Number two is capacity, expressed as jobs per week. Not revenue capacity. Jobs the crew can actually complete well. Write down your realistic weekly output per crew, then multiply by crews, then subtract the slack winter already promised to maintenance work. The gap between that number and your booked summer volume is your hiring decision, made months before the scramble. One number, one decision, and it is cheaper to make in January than in June.
Number three is a calendar with named weeks. Not a list of goals. Dates. When the fall maintenance mailer goes out. When price changes take effect. When the spring hiring window closes. When the website and the service pages get their annual review. A named week is the difference between "we should update the site before the season" and a block of time in February where the update gets done. Strategy lives or dies in the calendar, and the calendar is where most strategy documents quietly end.
These three numbers trade off against each other, and that trade is the real strategy conversation. Cash buys capacity: a hire in February costs three months of runway before the season pays for the position. Capacity buys cash: one more crew in June is revenue that would otherwise go to a competitor. The calendar is the lever that moves both: a winter hire is affordable, a July hire is not, and the same growth decision changes price entirely depending on the week you commit to it. Owners argue about growth when what they are actually deciding is which of the three to spend down first.
The December job list
Winter is the season where the owner is the only one who can do certain work, and the list is short enough to name:
- Pricing. Review your rates against the year you just had. Every year material and labor move, and most service businesses underprice by default because they set prices during busy months, when the easy answer is to stay put. The price change should take effect before the season opens, so the first spring quote is priced on purpose.
- Service menu. Cut what loses money and promote what margin-rich. The drain call that costs more to run than it bills has a price problem or a place in the trash. Decide now, in a quiet month, not mid-July when the truck is already rolling.
- Hiring plan. Decide the crews and roles you need by May, and start the interviews in January. Hiring when the phone is ringing means hiring whoever walks in. Hiring in a quiet month means hiring someone who passed a real interview.
- Systems. The follow-up automation, the quoting template, the invoice flow, the review request. Each of these is a December afternoon, and each one saves an hour a day once the season starts. Set them up when the mistakes cost nothing.
- Marketing. The website pages, the local search presence, the ad campaigns that need a landing page and a budget. Search work done in January is in place for the April spike. Search work started in May is two months late for the whole season.
- Supplier agreements. Winter is when distributors have time for you and your volume commitment means something. The price and the terms you lock in December follow you into summer.
None of this is glamorous, and all of it is the difference between a business that starts the season ready and one that spends April catching up to decisions it should have made in January.
What the plan looks like for four different businesses
The same framework lands differently depending on the trade, so here are four examples of the shape.
A one-truck handyman around Lapeer has capacity as the binding constraint. The calendar is the whole strategy: cap jobs per week, raise prices until the week is full of the jobs you want, and use the winter lull to book spring weekends before they open. His cash number is small, so the pricing decision is also the hiring decision. The moment the week overfills is the moment the second truck conversation begins, and the runway to fund it is what he is saving in the first place.
A residential plumbing shop in Grand Blanc has demand that outruns capacity every summer. Their plan is capacity first: hire the helper in January, train in February, and spend the season at full crews instead of full trucks and missed calls. Pricing follows capacity. A shop that can take one more job a week does not need to win every call on price, and the margin earned at full capacity funds the next hire. Their fall is the maintenance push: furnace checks, water heater swaps, winterization. Their winter is systems and pricing.
A commercial lawn operation across Genesee County sells contracts that renew in March, so winter is not downtime, it is sales season. Every renewal conversation that happens in January is a season locked in. The cash number that matters is what the season's contracts cover of the winter burn, and the capacity question is crew count at spring start. Their version one mistake is signing new contracts in May at discount prices to fill trucks that were not sold in winter.
An HVAC company lives in the wave. Summer is install season at full crews, fall is maintenance season, and the strategy is to ride both deliberately: price the installs to protect the summer, and build the maintenance base in the fall that carries the winter. Their version of the December list is heavier on marketing, because the AC tune-up mailer has to land in April to matter, and their version of capacity is the technician bench, which decides how many install weeks they can promise without promising overtime.
Four trades, one pattern: identify the binding constraint, then build the plan around easing it at the cheapest time of year, which is always the quiet one.
The cash rhythm that makes the plan real
The wave economy creates a cash rhythm most owners know in their bones but rarely write down. Work done in June gets paid in July or August, sometimes September for commercial jobs. Margin earned in summer sits in the account through fall. Winter burns it at a steady rate while revenue slows to a crawl. If billing drifts, the wave moves right: the November jobs get invoiced in February, and the business shows a great-looking margin in November and a cash problem in February, which is exactly when nobody is watching.
The fix is unglamorous. Invoice within a week of completion, collect before the holidays, and run a monthly close so you know where you stand before the slow months rather than discovering it in them. A business that knows its runway by the 10th of each month can make hiring and spending decisions with a quarter's more confidence than one that finds out at tax time.
One more rhythm note: the price increase belongs in the slow months, not the busy ones. Raising prices in February, when jobs are few and every customer conversation is short, is easier than raising them in July, when the phone is ringing and the easy move is to hold the old price to keep the day moving. Announce the change, apply it to new quotes, and the season starts on the new rates.
Capacity, again, because it breaks first
Every growth plan has a number that breaks first, and for a service business that number is almost always capacity, not demand. The question to ask before you commit to any growth number for next year: what breaks first, and when? Usually it is one of three things. Licensed hands: a plumber can only sell what a licensed plumber can do, and licenses take time. Crews: a truck without a two-person crew is a truck that runs at half speed. Or the owner: the business that can only run as fast as the person who knows how everything works. Each constraint has a different fix, and the fixes have lead times measured in months, which is why the planning belongs in the quiet season where there is time to execute them.
The capacity number also settles the argument about whether to grow. If the answer is "we cannot take more jobs without hiring," the plan is a hiring plan. If the answer is "we have idle capacity in the mornings," the plan is a marketing plan. Same business, opposite plan, and the difference is one number written down honestly.
What to stop doing in the name of strategy
Three habits masquerade as strategy and cost real money:
- Collecting goals without dates. "Grow revenue 20 percent" is a wish. "Hire one tech in January, raise prices in February, book 40 more installs by August" is a plan. Goals without a week attached to them do not survive contact with a busy Monday.
- Measuring everything except the numbers that decide anything. Pageviews and follower counts are noise for a service business. Jobs booked, revenue per crew week, cash on hand, and cost per booked job are the four numbers that set direction.
- Confusing busy seasons with good performance. A July that ran the crews ragged and earned thin margins is not a good quarter. The measure that matters is margin per crew week, and it is visible only if you look for it, ideally while the season is still running so there is time to change anything.
None of these is a character flaw. They are defaults that go away when the three real numbers exist on a page you actually look at.
What to do this week
One hour, before December fills up. Write down the three numbers: cash on hand, months of slow-season runway, and realistic weekly capacity. Then name three weeks on the calendar between now and April: the week the price list changes, the week the hiring plan starts, the week the website and service pages get their once-over. If you want the marketing half of this scheduled rather than remembered, the growth scorecard takes about five minutes and gives you a baseline to compare against in the spring, and a booking page is here if you would rather talk it through with a person: take the growth scorecard or book a growth assessment.
The point of all of it is to spend the quiet season on purpose. The wave comes whether you plan for it or not. The businesses that come out of a Michigan winter ahead are the ones that used the quiet to make decisions the wave would have made for them, badly, at the worst possible price.
Want a second opinion on your marketing?
Marvin Growth Partners works with service businesses across Michigan and nationwide. Book a Growth Assessment or take the Growth Scorecard to see where your lead flow stands.